Hi, I create my own map with 'boundary=administrative & admin_level=2' in the line style file to display the German boundary. I made a sreenshot (available at http://ge.tt/57JRmwj) where you can see the gaps. The boundary is a relation with the ID 51477. The relation itself has no gaps as far as I could estimate. Any hints? Thanks Josef -- PGP Schlüssel: 311D1055 http://keyserver.pgp.com
On 03/18/2011 02:55 PM, Josef Latt wrote:
I create my own map with 'boundary=administrative & admin_level=2' in the line style file to display the German boundary. I made a sreenshot (available at http://ge.tt/57JRmwj) where you can see the gaps. The boundary is a relation with the ID 51477.
What's your data source? Are you sure that all ways which make up the border are in your source file?
Am 18.03.2011 18:35, schrieb Ralf Kleineisel:
On 03/18/2011 02:55 PM, Josef Latt wrote:
I create my own map with 'boundary=administrative & admin_level=2' in the line style file to display the German boundary. I made a sreenshot (available at http://ge.tt/57JRmwj) where you can see the gaps. The boundary is a relation with the ID 51477.
What's your data source? Are you sure that all ways which make up the border are in your source file?
Yes I'm. Extract from europe.osm.pbf (geofabrik) with a selfcreated polygon file. I tried also an extract with a bounding box (values from your HowTo). The complete Europe map, which I tried had also gaps in the boundary, even in other countries. -- PGP Schlüssel: 311D1055 http://keyserver.pgp.com
On 03/18/2011 07:29 PM, Josef Latt wrote:
Yes I'm.
Extract from europe.osm.pbf (geofabrik) with a selfcreated polygon file. I tried also an extract with a bounding box (values from your HowTo).
Perhaps parts of the border are also used by other tags, e.g. "natural=river + boundary=administrative". If you have a rule in your style which matches the "natural=river" you won't get the border.
Yes I'm.
Extract from europe.osm.pbf (geofabrik) with a selfcreated polygon file. I tried also an extract with a bounding box (values from your HowTo).
Perhaps parts of the border are also used by other tags, e.g. "natural=river + boundary=administrative". If you have a rule in your style which matches the "natural=river" you won't get the border.
It's definitely a shortcoming in the multipolygon processing. WanMil
Josef, you are right. Some parts of the boundary are not created although the ways are in the tile. The reason is the incomplete boundary relation which cannot be fully processed by the multipolygon algorithm. Can you try the patch? This fixes that the ways of a multipolygon are tagged with the multipolygon tags no matter if the mulitpolygon could be processed successfully. WanMil
Hi,
I create my own map with 'boundary=administrative& admin_level=2' in the line style file to display the German boundary. I made a sreenshot (available at http://ge.tt/57JRmwj) where you can see the gaps. The boundary is a relation with the ID 51477.
The relation itself has no gaps as far as I could estimate.
Any hints?
Thanks Josef
Hi Wanmil, means that I have to build mkgmap. Don't know how to do this. Can you send me a build with this patch? Greetings Josef Am 18.03.2011 19:27, schrieb WanMil:
Josef,
you are right. Some parts of the boundary are not created although the ways are in the tile. The reason is the incomplete boundary relation which cannot be fully processed by the multipolygon algorithm.
Can you try the patch? This fixes that the ways of a multipolygon are tagged with the multipolygon tags no matter if the mulitpolygon could be processed successfully.
WanMil
Hi,
I create my own map with 'boundary=administrative& admin_level=2' in the line style file to display the German boundary. I made a sreenshot (available at http://ge.tt/57JRmwj) where you can see the gaps. The boundary is a relation with the ID 51477.
The relation itself has no gaps as far as I could estimate.
Any hints?
Thanks Josef
_______________________________________________ mkgmap-dev mailing list mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
-- PGP Schlüssel: 311D1055 http://keyserver.pgp.com
I got a positive feedback from Josef about this patch. If nobody disagrees I will commit today. WanMil
Josef,
you are right. Some parts of the boundary are not created although the ways are in the tile. The reason is the incomplete boundary relation which cannot be fully processed by the multipolygon algorithm.
Can you try the patch? This fixes that the ways of a multipolygon are tagged with the multipolygon tags no matter if the mulitpolygon could be processed successfully.
WanMil
Hi,
I create my own map with 'boundary=administrative& admin_level=2' in the line style file to display the German boundary. I made a sreenshot (available at http://ge.tt/57JRmwj) where you can see the gaps. The boundary is a relation with the ID 51477.
The relation itself has no gaps as far as I could estimate.
Any hints?
Thanks Josef
_______________________________________________ mkgmap-dev mailing list mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
participants (3)
-
Josef Latt -
Ralf Kleineisel -
WanMil