At least since version of 12/02/2010 I'm getting some weird turn instructions in places where they worked fine in the past . In this area [1] I get two of these estrange instructions when driving SE from "Avenida Cordel de Merinas" to SW in "Avenida Hernán Cortés". The sequence of instructions (both MapSource and gps) is: 1-Turn right at Avenida de Extremadura (OK) 2-Turn left at Avenida de las Delicias (wrong) 3-Turn right at Avenida de las Delicias (OK) 4-Turn right at Avenida Hernán Cortés (wrong) At 2 there's been no change in the data for a long time. I noticed 4 first time after creating a through_route relation to avoid a "keep left" instruction, but the problem could have been there before. nuvi gives another wrong "turn right" at 3.5 [1] http://www.informationfreeway.org/?lat=39.482090468611915&lon=-6.37191689825...
Hi Carlos,
At least since version of 12/02/2010 I'm getting some weird turn instructions in places where they worked fine in the past . In this area [1] I get two of these estrange instructions when driving SE from "Avenida Cordel de Merinas" to SW in "Avenida Hernán Cortés". The sequence of instructions (both MapSource and gps) is: 1-Turn right at Avenida de Extremadura (OK) 2-Turn left at Avenida de las Delicias (wrong) 3-Turn right at Avenida de las Delicias (OK) 4-Turn right at Avenida Hernán Cortés (wrong) At 2 there's been no change in the data for a long time. I noticed 4 first time after creating a through_route relation to avoid a "keep left" instruction, but the problem could have been there before. nuvi gives another wrong "turn right" at 3.5
[1] http://www.informationfreeway.org/?lat=39.482090468611915&lon=-6.37191689825...
Yes, there is a recently introduced regression. I know which commit introduced it but haven't had time to investigate fully. I hope to have a fix real soon. Mark
Hi Carlos,
At least since version of 12/02/2010 I'm getting some weird turn instructions in places where they worked fine in the past . In this area [1] I get two of these estrange instructions when driving SE from "Avenida Cordel de Merinas" to SW in "Avenida Hernán Cortés". The sequence of instructions (both MapSource and gps) is: 1-Turn right at Avenida de Extremadura (OK) 2-Turn left at Avenida de las Delicias (wrong) 3-Turn right at Avenida de las Delicias (OK) 4-Turn right at Avenida Hernán Cortés (wrong) At 2 there's been no change in the data for a long time. I noticed 4 first time after creating a through_route relation to avoid a "keep left" instruction, but the problem could have been there before. nuvi gives another wrong "turn right" at 3.5
With that patch I posted earlier, this route is fine now in mapsource (no spurious directions). Are you still seeing problems with that route? Cheers, Mark
Mark, Would it be because of that regression that whendriving that route ( http://maps.cloudmade.com/?lat=42.560106&lng=-83.18043&zoom=17&directions=42...) the only instruction you get is "Turn right in Golfview Dr"? Thanks, N.
Hi Nakor,
Would it be because of that regression that whendriving that route ( http://maps.cloudmade.com/?lat=42.560106&lng=-83.18043&zoom=17&directions=42...) the only instruction you get is "Turn right in Golfview Dr"?
I don't think so - I just tried with and without that fix and mapsource told me the same in both cases: 1. WBigBeaverRd 0 m 0:00:00 N42.56177 W83.17316 2. Get on W Big Beaver Rd and drive west 0 m 0 m 0:00:00 0:00:00 90° true N42.56177 W83.17316 3. Turn left onto Lakeview Dr ramp 586 m 586 m 0:00:50 0:00:50 268° true N42.56155 W83.18030 4. Turn right onto Golfview Dr 969 m 383 m 0:01:04 0:01:54 177° true N42.55870 W83.18120 Cheers, Mark
Mark Burton escribió:
Hi Carlos,
At least since version of 12/02/2010 I'm getting some weird turn instructions in places where they worked fine in the past . In this area [1] I get two of these estrange instructions when driving SE from "Avenida Cordel de Merinas" to SW in "Avenida Hernán Cortés". The sequence of instructions (both MapSource and gps) is: 1-Turn right at Avenida de Extremadura (OK) 2-Turn left at Avenida de las Delicias (wrong) 3-Turn right at Avenida de las Delicias (OK) 4-Turn right at Avenida Hernán Cortés (wrong) At 2 there's been no change in the data for a long time. I noticed 4 first time after creating a through_route relation to avoid a "keep left" instruction, but the problem could have been there before. nuvi gives another wrong "turn right" at 3.5
With that patch I posted earlier, this route is fine now in mapsource (no spurious directions). Are you still seeing problems with that route? Yes: Turn left at 2 has disappeared, good! Now at 3 instruction is keep right, which is wrong. Turn right is still said at 4, where there's a through_route relation, so no instruction should be said (if one, it should be keep left).
I have another case at [1]: 1: enter roundabout (ok) 2: take first to the right (ok) 3: turn left at Calle Osa Mayor (ok) 4: turn left at Calle Osa Mayor (wrong) [1] http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=39.47593&lon=-6.39121&zoom=17&layers=B000F...
participants (3)
-
Carlos Dávila -
Mark Burton -
Nakor Osm