Commit: r2092: Translate motor_vehicle and vehicle access rules.
Version 2092 was commited by marko on 2011-11-16 07:48:45 +0000 (Wed, 16 Nov 2011) Translate motor_vehicle and vehicle access rules.
Marko, I see that the default style now effectively translates motor_vehicle to motorcar. Looking at the wiki and according to my understanding, motor_vehicle is a hypernym covering motorcar, hgv, psv etc etc. So now motor_vehicle=no will prohibit cars, but allow buses and trucks? Not sure if it is any better, but I have the following to handle motor_vehicle, which basically prohibits everything and then allows things which are not counted as a motor vehicle. highway=* & motor_vehicle!=yes {add access='${motor_vehicle}'; add foot=yes; add bicycle=yes; add mofa=yes; add moped=yes; add horse=yes} Colin On 16/11/2011 08:48, svn commit wrote:
Version 2092 was commited by marko on 2011-11-16 07:48:45 +0000 (Wed, 16 Nov 2011)
Translate motor_vehicle and vehicle access rules. _______________________________________________ mkgmap-dev mailing list mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
On Wed, Nov 16, 2011 at 10:29:08AM +0100, Colin Smale wrote:
I see that the default style now effectively translates motor_vehicle to motorcar. Looking at the wiki and according to my understanding, motor_vehicle is a hypernym covering motorcar, hgv, psv etc etc. So now motor_vehicle=no will prohibit cars, but allow buses and trucks?
There is no special bus routing in the Garmin map format, is there? I think that we should concentrate on the routing flags that exist in the Garmin format. One thing that may be broken because of this is is 'delivery', 'emergency' and 'taxi' routing. Does anyone know how these work, and have suggestions how to fix this or other special routing? Not being a Windows or Mac OS X user, the only routing that I can try is the one on my Garmin Edge 705. It only supports foot, bicycle, car(shortest) and car(fastest) with some avoidance options (unpaved roads, major roads, toll roads).
Not sure if it is any better, but I have the following to handle motor_vehicle, which basically prohibits everything and then allows things which are not counted as a motor vehicle.
highway=* & motor_vehicle!=yes {add access='${motor_vehicle}'; add foot=yes; add bicycle=yes; add mofa=yes; add moped=yes; add horse=yes}
The mofa, moped, horse should be ignored by mkgmap, unless you have other rules that depend on them. There could be some strange combination of (conflicting) access parameters where your rule works better than mine, or where my rule works better than yours. I am open to change the rule I committed if I get some examples. Best regards, Marko
On 16.11.2011 12:18, Marko Mäkelä wrote:
On Wed, Nov 16, 2011 at 10:29:08AM +0100, Colin Smale wrote:
I see that the default style now effectively translates motor_vehicle to motorcar. Looking at the wiki and according to my understanding, motor_vehicle is a hypernym covering motorcar, hgv, psv etc etc. So now motor_vehicle=no will prohibit cars, but allow buses and trucks? There is no special bus routing in the Garmin map format, is there? There is, but newest firmware tends to completely overlook the prohibitions. AFAIK Garmin never used them in their non NT maps, hence they start to boot them out. All prohibitions that exist in Mapsource, also (existed) on Garmin GPS. Newer Firmwares/Devices before started to only offer a few of them and not using truck, bus, taxi, emergency anymore.
Still for those that do use an older device, they should be included.
On Wed, Nov 16, 2011 at 12:29:01PM +0100, Felix Hartmann wrote:
On 16.11.2011 12:18, Marko Mäkelä wrote:
On Wed, Nov 16, 2011 at 10:29:08AM +0100, Colin Smale wrote:
I see that the default style now effectively translates motor_vehicle to motorcar. Looking at the wiki and according to my understanding, motor_vehicle is a hypernym covering motorcar, hgv, psv etc etc. So now motor_vehicle=no will prohibit cars, but allow buses and trucks? There is no special bus routing in the Garmin map format, is there? There is, but newest firmware tends to completely overlook the prohibitions. AFAIK Garmin never used them in their non NT maps, hence they start to boot them out. All prohibitions that exist in Mapsource, also (existed) on Garmin GPS. Newer Firmwares/Devices before started to only offer a few of them and not using truck, bus, taxi, emergency anymore.
Still for those that do use an older device, they should be included.
Could you suggest a patch then? Marko
participants (4)
-
Colin Smale -
Felix Hartmann -
Marko Mäkelä -
svn commit