Hi Gerd A few more things I've discovered. GPSMapEdit will show bands of emptyness for a thin, correct, slice when you zoom out but with the view zoom level locked at a higher resolution than it expects. This confused some of my previous findings. Changing some sizes changes the behaviour and I sometimes get the holes at level 1 but level 2 is OK. 3 of the edges of the hole correspond to cut-lines to get at the cluster of 'islands', but the 4th corresponds to the subdivision max -size splitting, so it looks like the problem might be related to MapBuilder/MapSplitter/MapArea logic. With option --x-no-mergeshapes (and current trunk) it appears that cutting to this island group happens twice from the left, with 1 line continuing to the right and twice from the top, with 1 line continuing to the bottom. Ticker On Sun, 2021-04-25 at 13:50 +0100, Ticker Berkin wrote:
Hi Gerd
More more testing with standard style / options etc. As well as - -order -by, I had some level params that confused.
With GPSMapEdit at Zoom level 2, there is a wide cut from the LHS forest triangle to the holes around 54.9953,-58.2209. It seems to be the total height of the holes.
Similar shows in MapSource, but it much more difficult to find. Resolution needs to be <= 7mi before forest kicks-in. I didn't investigate how far left the blank area went.
Looking more closely on Basecamp, the blank area is a rectangle approx 54.975,-58.302 to 55.0178,-58.6247, ie it doesn't go to the edge of the forest triangle. Also it only shows when detail-level is set to "highest"
Ticker
On Sun, 2021-04-25 at 11:03 +0100, Ticker Berkin wrote:
Hi Gerd
Just tried this with latest trunk and my standard environment (mainly --order-by-decreasing-area and get very inconsistent results.
On GPSMapEdit seems reasonable - shows forest triangle and, within, a small area with a number of holes.
MapSource shows a white square, no forest colour and I can't move the map around, also it doesn't seem to zoom out enough. First time I looked I saw 2 white squares.
Basecamp shows the forest triangle, but I can't find the islands/holes
I've had problems before with MapSource or Basecamp caches, so I'll delete these. Also try with simple options etc
Ticker
On Sun, 2021-04-25 at 07:31 +0000, Gerd Petermann wrote:
Hi Experts,
while working on the faster-mp branch I experimented with the monster relation r9488835. I added tag landuse=forest to it so that it is actually rendered and found huge (wrong) empty rectangles in the forest. The original file is very complex but the same problem also occurs with a simplified file, see http://files.mkgmap.org.uk/download/505/bad-map-split.osm.pbf Just use e.g. java -jar mkgmap.jar --gmapi bad-map-split.osm.pbf Problem: Basecamp and Mapsource don't show this map, GpsMapEdit shows a large white rectangle near 54.97743 -58.30292
I assume that we hit some unknown limit , possibly in LinePreparer or MapSplitter. I've also tried some older versions, so far they all show the problem. Any idea where to look?
RgnDisplay shows this data for the problemat area: --------- Level 0, Subdiv 279 ----------------------------------- -- -- ----------- | | | final at 265f, (end 25e2) | | | polygon start 2634 to 265f 00002634 | 000000 | 4b | Polygon 1 | | | Type 0x4b 00002635 | 000001 | 00 00 00 | Label offset: 0x000000 () 00002638 | 000004 | d0 3b | Long delta 15312 0000263a | 000006 | 2a 3a | Lat delta 14890 | | | Start point 55.24913, -61.91139 2574796/-2885280 0000263c | 000008 | 0c | Bitstream length 12 0000263d | 000009 | bb | Base bb 0000263e | 00000a | 06 43 04 00 00 00 4c d1 | Bitstream (len: 12, 0xc) 00002646 | 000012 | 41 ef 00 00 | | | | xsame false, xneg false | | | ysame true, yneg true | | | xbase 16, ybase 15 | | | Coord 55.24913, -62.56851 2574796/-2915904 [-30624,+0] | | | Coord 54.61014, -62.56851 2545017/-2915904 [+0,-29779] | | | Coord 54.61014, -61.91139 2545017/-2885280 [+30624,+0] | | | 0 bits left, 0 | | | 0000264a | 000016 | 50 | Polygon 2 | | | Type 0x50 0000264b | 000017 | 00 00 00 | Label offset: 0x000000 () 0000264e | 00001a | d0 3b | Long delta 15312 00002650 | 00001c | b4 08 | Lat delta 2228 | | | Start point 54.97743, -61.91139 2562134/-2885280 00002652 | 00001e | 0b | Bitstream length 11 00002653 | 00001f | 9b | Base 9b 00002654 | 000020 | f2 8d 04 40 a7 fe d0 4b | Bitstream (len: 11, 0xb) 0000265c | 000028 | e7 00 00 | | | | xsame false, xneg false | | | ysame true, yneg false | | | xbase 16, ybase 11 | | | Coord 54.97743, -62.51706 2562134/-2913506 [-28226,+0] | | | Coord 55.01732, -62.54665 2563993/-2914885 [-1379,+1859] | | | Coord 55.01732, -61.91139 2563993/-2885280 [+29605,+0] | | | 4 bits left, 0 | | |
Gerd _______________________________________________ mkgmap-dev mailing list mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
mkgmap-dev mailing list mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev
mkgmap-dev mailing list mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk https://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev