Update, previous version had some errors, conclusion is the same
|
Build date |
Mkgmap |
Device |
Style |
Pink line |
Crash/Deadloop |
Result |
Comment |
|
|
24-8-2017 |
r3995
|
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
r4195 |
Felix Hartmann |
Felix Personal |
? |
Wrong |
Felix thinks he uses this version and his own style but is not sure |
|||
|
16-4-2019 |
r4286 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
26-10-2019 |
r4323 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
|
r4358 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
|
r4359 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
|
r4360 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
This is what Ticker suspected and also Steve suggested. 4360 introduced new routing behaviour by design |
|
|
r4361 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
|
r4372 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Orginally tested with jar file supplied by Jan Meisters: Thought it was oke!, still have the working img, but I cannot prove
again this img was really created by that version. The Jar version of Steve creates an img that is not oke? 2nd & 3th time compile again with Jan's jar file to double check also suddenly is wrong: So I must have made a mistake in copy/paste or documenting
the testresults. Conclusion 4373 is not oke |
|
17-11-2019 |
r4373 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
r4374 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
||
|
r4376 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
||
|
r4379 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
||
|
6-12-2019 |
r4384 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
8-12-2019 |
r4386 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
25-1-2020 |
r4431 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
? |
Wrong |
|
|
r4479 |
Jan Meisters |
Oregon 450 |
Jan Personal |
No |
No |
Half |
||
|
19-6-2020 |
r4551 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
19-6-2020 |
r4551 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Joris Personal |
No |
No |
Half |
|
Van: mkgmap-dev <mkgmap-dev-bounces@lists.mkgmap.org.uk>
Namens Joris Bo
Verzonden: maandag 29 juni 2020 11:05
Aan: Development list for mkgmap <mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk>
Onderwerp: Re: [mkgmap-dev] Routing problem on Garmin Oregon/edge with default style (and other styles)
Hi
I finished testing and it narrows down to 4360
Kind regards, Joris
|
Build date |
Mkgmap |
Device |
Style |
Pink line |
Crash/Deadloop |
Result |
Comment |
|
|
24-8-2017 |
r3995
|
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
r4195 |
Felix Hartmann |
Felix Personal |
? |
Wrong |
Felix thinks he uses this version and his own style but is not sure |
|||
|
16-4-2019 |
r4286 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
26-10-2019 |
r4323 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
|
r4358 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
|
r4359 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
Yes |
No |
Ok |
|
|
|
r4360 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
No |
Wrong |
This is what Ticker suspected and also Steve suggested. 4360 introduced new routing behavior by design |
|
|
r4361 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
No |
Wrong |
|
|
|
r4372 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
No |
Wrong |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Orginally tested with jar file supplied by Jan Meisters: Thought it was oke!, still have the working img, but I cannot prove
again this img was really created by that version. The Jar version of Steve creates an img that is not oke? 2nd & 3th time compile again with Jan's jar file to double check also suddenly is wrong: So I must have made a mistake in copy/paste or documenting
the testresults. Conclusion 4373 is not oke |
|
17-11-2019 |
r4373 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
No |
Wrong |
|
|
r4374 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
||
|
r4376 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
||
|
r4379 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
||
|
6-12-2019 |
r4384 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
8-12-2019 |
r4386 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
25-1-2020 |
r4431 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
? |
Wrong |
|
|
r4479 |
Jan Meisters |
Oregon 450 |
Jan Personal |
No |
No |
Half |
||
|
19-6-2020 |
r4551 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Default 2020 |
No |
Yes |
Wrong |
|
|
19-6-2020 |
r4551 |
Joris Bo |
Oregon 650 |
Joris Personal |
No |
No |
Half |
|
-----Oorspronkelijk bericht-----
Van: mkgmap-dev <mkgmap-dev-bounces@lists.mkgmap.org.uk> Namens Steve Ratcliffe
Verzonden: zondag 28 juni 2020 10:22
Aan: mkgmap-dev@lists.mkgmap.org.uk
Onderwerp: Re: [mkgmap-dev] Routing problem on Garmin Oregon/edge with default style (and other styles)
Hi Joris
> Based on the versions supplied I could bring it down to 4373 still being > OK and 4384 reveals the problem
Thanks for narrowing it down.
There was a large change not long before that in version 4360 with the merge of the NET-no-NOD branch that did affect the routing a lot.
It causes the NodCheck utility to crash, I don't know why yet.
I've put all precompiled jar files at:
http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/jars/
Steve
_______________________________________________
mkgmap-dev mailing list