data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c125b/c125b853f0995d45aaac92eceb3ca5c1f81f52f5" alt=""
On the Finnish forum, the senior mapper alv pointed out that the left:*, right:* names for boundary=administrative ways are being made obsolete by boundary relations. I agree with him that boundary relations are the better option, especially with regards to localization. mkgmap can replace name with some other tag, such as name:sv for Swedish, but it would be difficult to have it replace a family of left:*, right:* tags with left:*:sv, right:*:sv. So, I tried to define a relations rule that would generate a space-separated list of names for a boundary line. For example, the boundary=administrative line http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/way/38589207 that belongs to the relations of the city borders Vantaa and Helsinki and to the Helsinki suburban borders Tapulikaupunki and Suutarila should get all these names, "Vantaa/Helsinki/Tapulikaupunki/Suutarila", in some order. What happens is that it will get just one of the names, "Suutarila" in my test run: In the relations file, I had this, trying to append each relation name to the mkgmap:boundary_name attribute of each relation member: (type=boundary | type=multipolygon) & boundary=administrative & name=* { echo '${name}'; apply { set mkgmap:boundary_name='${mkgmap:boundary_name}/${name}' | '${name}'; echo '${mkgmap:boundary_name}' } } The problem is that within apply{}, the variable substitutions on the right-hand-side of the "set" and "add" action always refer to the tags of the relation, not to the relation member. Thus, mkgmap:boundary_name will always be empty, and only one relation name will be copied to it. One possible solution is to have a special form of apply{} where SubAction.performOnSubElements(Relation rel) does not invoke addTagAction.setValueTags(rel). A patch that introduces the action apply_local{} is attached. An alternative solution would be to have a special form of variable substitution that refers to the tags of the element itself. One simple way of implementing that could be to introduce the keywords set_local and add_local and add another boolean parameter to AddTagAction that would imply valueTags == null. Yet another solution would be to have a special syntax of variable substitution that would bypass the valueTags, say, $(var) instead of ${var}: (type=boundary | type=multipolygon) & boundary=administrative & name=* { apply { set mkgmap:boundary_name='$(mkgmap:boundary_name)/${name}' | '${name}'; } } Best regards, Marko